Post

School Captain Election in Shambles Again

Yet again, the elections for our school leaders have been an absolute clown-show.

On the 2nd of February (Friday Week 1), an announcement was made on the Senior Campus noticeboard: if you’re interested in becoming a School Captain, please fill out the form. Having the expression of interest form released on the first week of school is incredibly early, but alright. Could be a once off thing.

A week later, on the 12th of February (Monday Week 3), a second announcement was made stating that voting was open, and due the next day. This was the first mistake. Having the results for an election due the next day was an incredibly short window of time, and Google Classroom notifications are notoriously slow. There was a chance that if you weren’t fast enough, you could miss the opportunity to have your say. What if you’re sick? What if you’re busy? At least the prime minister election cycle has a whole weekend at minimum.

Later that day, there was another announcement:

Year Captain voting form deleted? Year Captain voting form deleted?

They just deleted the form out of thin air? Why? What happened to all the responses? Now everyone who responded to the original form had to do it again! What were they thinking? Can’t they just edit the existing form instead of deleting and recreating it? It’s ridiculous.

On top of that, on the updated form1, it wasn’t possible to vote for two people! It wasn’t configured as a tick box form, which can let you pick more than one option, there wasn’t even a second “who do you want for the other school captain?” box! This system of voting is known as “First Past the Post” and is notoriously bad, especially considering there are two Captains, not one!

Alright, so they might have opened the expression of interest forms a bit early. Maybe they might have had to elect the captains super early, so they need a short deadline. They could have made a big mistake on the forms and decided to delete and recreate it. The people making the form probably didn’t know what they were doing, or didn’t know about alternative voting systems. But how can they intentionally not invite the students to listen to the speeches!

Speeches make or break elections! Especially considering the Year 10’s have had little to no contact with the older year groups, or know who they would want to vote for! Nobody at the High School campus even knows the candidates (if they were even included). So how are we meant to pick the captains we want if we don’t even know who we’re voting for? I only cast my vote the way I did because the two names I recognised on the form were people in my drama class! Its insane!

On top of all of this, we don’t even know who our Year Captains are, or if there’s even going to be a re-election, which looks incredibly rare considering we haven’t had a re-election ever! I personally want to see new leadership representing my year level, not people who we picked over two years ago still representing us2.

Melba Copland, pull your stuff together, and give us representation by people we actually think represent us.

Update 29/02/2024

As of the 29th of Feb, Year Captain Elections have been announced through SOBS. The Pipeline will be reporting on the election throughout.

Footnotes

  1. I didn’t have access to the original form, for those who did please let me know if this was consistent across both of them! ↩

  2. People who won by 3 votes, mind you. 3 votes! Out of hundreds! At least that election was the alternative vote. ↩

This post is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 by the author.

Trending Tags